Hybrid, Memory Foam, or Innerspring? Comparing the Three Major Mattress Types
In this Article:
Buying a mattress is a big investment, and choosing the right one can significantly impact your sleep quality, and health. When shopping, start by asking yourself some important questions. Are you a side sleeper? Does your mattress feel too hot when you sleep? Do you wake up with aches and pains? Do you share your mattress with a partner?
This guide explores the three major mattress types—innerspring, hybrid, and memory foam — by comparing construction, feel, benefits, and drawbacks to help you find your perfect sleep surface.
The Basics of Each Mattress Type
Mattress technology has changed a lot in the last 10 to 15 years. You could say we are in a mattress renaissance. That said, there are still 3 major mattress types: innerspring, hybrid, and memory foam. Each has its pros and cons, and we’re here to help you understand the basics.
Innerspring Mattresses
Innerspring, aka spring mattress, is one of the oldest types of mattresses most people are familiar with. Steel coils are the main component in innerspring mattresses, providing primary support while the upper layers add cushioning and softness.
How it feels:
- Responsive, bouncy sleep surface with significant pushback
- “Sleeping on top” rather than “sinking in” sensation.
Benefits:
- Excellent breathability and cooling properties
- Strong edge support
- Responsive bounce for ease of movement
- Wide availability at various price points
- Familiar feel that many sleepers grew up with
Memory Foam Mattresses
Memory foam is a more recent innovation in mattresses, developed by NASA in the 1960s to use for cushioning and shock absorbency during takeoff. In the 1980s, the mattress industry embraced memory foam technology into its sleep surfaces, and the rest is history.
Memory foam mattresses consist of multiple layers of viscoelastic polyurethane foam. Top layers contain memory foam that responds to heat and pressure, contouring to your body, while denser base foam layers provide the foundational support.
How it feels:
- “Sinking in” or “hugging” feel, as opposed to the “sleeping on top” feeling of innerspring mattresses
- Contours closely to the body, creating a cradling, pressure-relieving sensation
Benefits
- Excellent pressure relief and motion isolation
- Quiet, no-noise design
- Deep contouring for spinal alignment
- Good durability when made with high-quality materials
Hybrid Mattresses
Hybrid mattresses are what the name implies – a hybrid that combines the benefits of both innerspring and memory foam mattresses. Introduced in 2008, hybrids are built using a coil support core and comfort layers made of memory foam, latex, or other materials.
How it feels:
- Balanced feel with the responsiveness of coils and the contouring of foam layers
Benefits
- Balanced support and comfort
- Better cooling than all-foam designs
- Enhanced pressure relief compared to traditional innersprings
- Reduced motion transfer compared to traditional innersprings
- Strong edge support with reinforced perimeters
Key Points:
- Innerspring mattresses have a bouncy, responsive feel
- Memory foam mattresses contour closely to the body
- Strong edge support is a key feature of innersprings
- Memory foam excels at pressure relief and motion isolation
Finding the Right Mattress Type Based on Your Sleep Style
Your sleep position and body type play an important role in determining which mattress will provide optimal comfort and support. Different sleeping positions create unique pressure points and alignment needs that each mattress type addresses differently.
Side sleepers need cushioning at the shoulders and hips, while back sleepers require lumbar support. Stomach sleepers need firmness to prevent midsection sinking, and combination sleepers benefit from responsive surfaces that accommodate movement.
Here’s how each mattress type performs based on the specific sleep style:
For Side Sleepers
Innerspring: Traditional innerspring mattresses often lack the pressure relief side sleepers need at the shoulders and hips. Without adequate comfort layers, they may create pressure points for side sleepers.
Memory Foam: These are highly recommended for side sleepers. The contouring properties of memory foam allow shoulders and hips to sink in while supporting the waist, promoting proper spinal alignment.
Hybrid: A good compromise for side sleepers who want pressure relief without the complete “hug” of memory foam. Quality hybrids with thick comfort layers provide adequate cushioning for pressure points while maintaining some responsiveness.
For Back Sleepers
Innerspring: Can work well for back sleepers who prefer a firmer, more supportive surface. Look for models with quality pillow tops or Euro tops if you desire additional cushioning.
Memory Foam: Medium-firm memory foam mattresses can provide excellent lumbar support for back sleepers by filling in the lower back curve while keeping the spine aligned.
Hybrid: Often ideal for back sleepers, offering supportive coils with enough foam cushioning to contour to the lower back’s natural curve.
For Stomach Sleepers
Innerspring: Often preferred by stomach sleepers who need a firmer surface to prevent excessive sinking of the midsection, which can cause lower back strain.
Memory Foam: Generally not recommended for stomach sleepers unless it’s a very firm model. Softer memory foam can allow the hips to sink too deeply, creating spinal misalignment.
Hybrid: Can work well for stomach sleepers if the model is firmer with minimal softness in the comfort layers. Look for reinforced support in the center third – like in our Nectar Ultra mattress model.
For Combination Sleepers
Innerspring: The responsive surface makes changing positions easier, which benefits combination sleepers who move frequently throughout the night.
Memory Foam: May create a “stuck” feeling for combination sleepers due to the slow response time when changing positions.
Hybrid: Often the best choice for combination sleepers, offering enough responsiveness for easy movement while providing adequate pressure relief in different positions.
Important Factors to Consider in Choosing Your Mattress
Firmness Levels
Mattress firmness significantly impacts comfort and support, and each mattress type offers distinct firmness characteristics.
Innerspring:
- Typically range from medium to firm
- Firmness is influenced by coil gauge (thickness) and comfort layer thickness
- Traditional innersprings tend to be firmer overall
Memory Foam:
- Available in soft, medium, and firm options
- Firmness is determined by foam density and thickness
- Even firm memory foam will have some contouring effect
Hybrid:
- Offers the widest range of firmness options
- Can be customized with various comfort layer materials and thicknesses
- Coil type and gauge affect the base firmness level
Pressure Relief
Pressure relief refers to how well a mattress distributes body weight to reduce stress on pressure points like shoulders, hips, and joints. The right level of pressure relief can improve sleep quality and reduce pain, particularly for side sleepers and those with joint issues.
Innerspring: Generally provides the least pressure relief of the three types. Traditional innerspring beds with minimal comfort layers may actually create pressure points, especially for side sleepers or those with joint pain.
Memory Foam: Excels at pressure relief. The material redistributes weight evenly and reduces pressure on sensitive areas like shoulders, hips, and knees. This makes memory foam an excellent choice for those with arthritis or joint pain.
Hybrid: Offers better pressure relief than innerspring models but typically less than pure memory foam mattresses. The degree of pressure relief depends on the thickness and quality of the comfort layers.
Motion Isolation
Motion isolation determines if you’ll feel your partner’s movements during sleep. Each mattress type handles motion transfer differently, with some designs absorbing movement while others allow it to travel across the sleep surface.
Innerspring: Traditional interconnected coil systems transfer motion significantly. Partners may feel each other’s movements throughout the night, though models with pocketed coils perform better.
Memory Foam: Memory foam has superior motion isolation capabilities. It absorbs and dampens movement, making it ideal for couples or light sleepers who are easily disturbed by their partner’s movements.
Hybrid: Hybrids have better motion isolation than traditional innersprings, but are typically not as effective as pure memory foam. Pocketed coils combine with foam layers to minimize motion transfer considerably.
Temperature Regulation
How a mattress manages heat can dramatically affect sleep quality, especially for those who tend to sleep hot. The materials and construction of each mattress type create different levels of breathability and cooling.
Innerspring: Excellent airflow through the coil system makes traditional innerspring mattresses naturally cooling. They’re often recommended for hot sleepers or those in warm climates.
Memory Foam: Traditional memory foam retains heat and can sleep warm. Advanced memory foams can be infused with gel, copper, graphite, or open-cell structures to improve cooling, but may still sleep warmer than other types.
Hybrid: Hybrids offer better temperature regulation than all-foam mattresses due to the airflow through the coil layer. Many hybrids also incorporate cooling technologies within their comfort layers to further enhance breathability.
Support for Heavier Body Types
Different mattress types offer varying levels of support and durability for heavier sleepers.
Proper support for individuals weighing over 230 pounds requires mattresses with specific structural elements to prevent excessive sinking and maintain alignment.
Innerspring: Offers good support for heavier individuals (230+ lbs), especially models with robust coil systems. Higher coil counts and thicker gauges provide better durability and support.
Memory Foam: May not provide adequate support for heavier sleepers unless it’s a high-density, firm model. Lower-density memory foam can compress too much, leading to poor alignment and faster wear.
Hybrid: Often ideal for heavier body types, combining strong coil support with comfort layers thick enough to prevent bottoming out. Look for models specifically designed with reinforced support.
Edge Support
Edge support refers to how well a mattress maintains its structure along the perimeter, affecting how much usable sleep surface you have along with how easy it is to get in and out of bed. Strong edge support extends the functional sleeping area and provides stability when sitting or sleeping near the mattress edge.
Innerspring: Traditional innerspring mattresses typically feature reinforced edges, providing excellent edge support for sitting and sleeping near the perimeter.
Memory Foam: Generally lacks robust edge support. The edges may compress significantly when sitting or sleeping near them, reducing your usable sleep surface.
Hybrid: Usually offers better edge support than memory foam mattresses, especially models with reinforced perimeter coils. Quality can vary widely based on construction.
Durability
A mattress’s lifespan depends on its materials, construction quality, and how well it maintains its supportive properties over time.
Innerspring: Traditional innerspring mattresses typically last 5-7 years. Lower-quality models may develop sagging and body impressions earlier, particularly in the center third.
Memory Foam: Quality memory foam mattresses can last 7-10 years. Durability largely depends on foam density—higher-density foams (5+ lbs/cubic foot for memory foam layers) last longer.
Hybrid: Average lifespan of 6-8 years, combining the durability aspects of both coils and foam. Premium hybrids with high-density foams and quality coil systems can last longer.
All Nectar mattresses – whether Memory Foam or Hybrid – include a Forever Warranty™. If your mattress wears out from regular use (even 15 years down the line!), we’ll repair or replace it free of charge.
Compatibility with Adjustable Bases
For those with adjustable bed frames, mattress flexibility determines whether it can bend without damage or performance issues. The internal structure of each mattress type affects its ability to conform to the various positions of an adjustable base while maintaining comfort and support.
Innerspring: Traditional innerspring mattresses with interconnected coil systems are generally not recommended for adjustable bases, as the rigid structure resists bending. Doing so may damage your mattress permanently.
Memory Foam: Memory foam mattresses are incredibly compatible with adjustable bases. Flexible foam layers bend easily with the base’s movements without damaging the mattress structure.
Hybrid: Most modern hybrids work well with adjustable bases, especially those with pocketed (or individually-wrapped) coil systems. Check manufacturer specifications, as some designs may be more compatible than others.
Price Range Comparison
Mattress pricing varies widely across types, with differences reflecting material quality, construction methods, and additional features. Understanding the typical price ranges helps set realistic budget expectations and determine the best value based on your specific sleep needs and available investment.
Innerspring:
- Entry-level: $500-$800 (Queen)
- Mid-range: $800-$1,200
- Premium: $1,200-$2,000+
Memory Foam:
- Entry-level: $600-$900 (Queen)
- Mid-range: $900-$1,500
- Premium: $1,500-$3,000+
Hybrid:
- Entry-level: $800-$1,200 (Queen)
- Mid-range: $1,200-$2,000
- Premium: $2,000-$3,500+
Mattress Types Comparison Chart: Innerspring vs. Hybrid vs. Memory Foam
| Feature | Innerspring | Memory Foam | Hybrid |
|---|---|---|---|
| Construction | Steel coils with thin comfort layers | Multiple layers of viscoelastic foam | Coil support core with substantial foam comfort layers |
| Feel | Responsive, bouncy, "sleeping on top" sensation | Contouring, cradling, "sinking in" sensation | Balanced feel combining responsiveness and contouring |
| Best For Sleep Positions | ✔ Back sleepers ✔ Stomach sleepers ✘ Most side sleepers | ✔ Side sleepers ✔ Back sleepers ✘ Most stomach sleepers | ✔ Combination sleepers ✔ All positions (with proper model) |
| Firmness Options | Typically medium to firm | Soft to firm available | Widest range of options |
| Pressure Relief | ★☆☆ (Low to moderate) | ★★★ (Excellent) | ★★☆ (Good to very good) |
| Motion Isolation | ★☆☆ (Poor to moderate) | ★★★ (Excellent) | ★★☆ (Good) |
| Temperature Regulation | ★★★ (Excellent) | ★★☆ (Good) | ★★☆ (Good) |
| Support for Heavier Body Types | ★★☆ (Good) | ★★☆ (Good) | ★★★ (Excellent) |
| Edge Support | ★★★ (Excellent) | ★☆☆ (Poor) | ★★☆ (Good to very good) |
| Adjustable Base Compatible | ✘ (Most traditional models) | ✔ (Excellent compatibility) | ✔ (Most models) |
| Noise Level | May produce some noise | Silent | Generally quiet |
| Average Price Range (Queen) | $500-$2,000+ | $600-$3,000+ | $800-$3,500+ |
Who Should Choose Each Mattress Type?
While no single mattress type works universally for everyone, each category—innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid— has its benefits.
Consider an Innerspring Mattress If You:
- Are a stomach or back sleeper who prefers a firmer feel
- Tend to sleep hot and prioritize cooling
- Want a responsive surface for ease of movement
- Are shopping on a tighter budget
- Need strong edge support
- Prefer a more traditional mattress feel
Consider a Memory Foam Mattress If You:
- Are a side sleeper or have pressure point pain
- Share a bed and are easily disturbed by your partner’s movements
- Enjoy the feeling of being cradled by your mattress
- Have arthritis or joint pain that benefits from pressure relief
- Prefer a silent, no-noise mattress
- Are willing to invest in cooling features if you sleep warm
Consider a Hybrid Mattress If You:
- Want balanced features from both innerspring and foam mattresses
- Are a combination sleeper who changes positions throughout the night
- Share a bed and need better motion isolation than traditional innersprings
- Need substantial pressure relief without the full “hug” of memory foam
- Are a heavier individual seeking adequate support and comfort
- Want cooling benefits with more contouring than traditional innersprings
Want to find the perfect mattress for you? Take our Mattress Quiz.
Other Factors to Consider in Your Mattress Decision
For Couples
Couples often benefit from mattresses with good motion isolation and edge support. While memory foam mattresses excel at preventing motion transfer, they lack the edge support provided by hybrid and innerspring mattresses. If you’re sharing a smaller mattress with your partner, edge support becomes more important. This makes hybrid and innerspring mattresses a more appealing choice for couples.
For Allergy Sufferers
Memory foam and many hybrid mattresses are inherently resistant to dust mites and mold, making them potentially better for allergy sufferers. However, some memory foams may off-gas more chemical odors initially. Innerspring mattresses can provide better airflow, which may help reduce allergen buildup, but their open structure can also harbor more dust mites if they’re used without proper covers.
For Those With Back Pain
The best mattress type for back pain depends on the individual’s sleep position and pain location. Side sleepers with back pain often benefit from memory foam’s pressure relief. Back sleepers may prefer the balanced support of a hybrid. A medium-firm feel across any mattress type is generally recommended for back pain, according to research.
Common Mattress Misconceptions
As you shop for a new mattress, you’ll likely encounter various claims about each mattress type that may influence your decision. However, many widely-held beliefs about innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid mattresses are outdated or oversimplified. Understanding these common misconceptions can help you make a more informed decision.
Claim: “Memory Foam Sleeps Hot”
While traditional memory foam was notorious for heat retention, modern memory foam mattresses often incorporate cooling technologies like gel infusions, phase-change materials, open-cell structures, or copper and graphite infusions to improve temperature regulation.
Claim: “Innerspring Mattresses Are Outdated”
Though innerspring technology has been around longer, many manufacturers continue to innovate with advanced coil systems, better comfort layers, and improved materials. Modern innerspring mattresses can offer excellent support, durability, and comfort.
Claim: “Hybrids Are Always Better Because They Combine Technologies”
While hybrids aim to offer the best of both worlds, they may not be best for everyone. Some sleepers prefer the feel of memory foam or traditional innerspring mattresses. Additionally, lower-quality hybrids may not provide the support and comfort expected from the hybrid construction.
Making Your Final Decision
When choosing between innerspring, memory foam, and hybrid mattresses, consider these final tips:
- Test before buying whenever possible, lying in your preferred sleep position for at least 10-15 minutes.
- Check return policies and trial periods, especially when purchasing online
Nectar features an industry-leading trial period, offering a full 365 days to sleep on your mattress before committing. - Consider your primary sleep position as the most important factor in your decision.
- Factor in your body weight, as different mattress types support different body types.
- Think about long-term value rather than just initial cost.
- Read the fine print about warranties and what they actually cover.
There is no single “best” mattress type—the right choice depends entirely on your individual needs, preferences, and budget. Innerspring mattresses offer responsiveness and cooling, memory foam provides exceptional pressure relief and motion isolation, and hybrids attempt to deliver a balanced experience by combining elements of both.
Understanding the key differences between these three major mattress types will help you make an informed decision that will lead to better sleep for years to come.
This article is for informational purposes and should not replace advice from your doctor or other medical professional.
